The Peptide CommonsEst. May 2024
Independent. We sell nothing and are affiliated with no manufacturer or pharmacy. Every moderation action is logged in public
Topic summary

Journal club: is percentage weight change the right endpoint?

This is a generated summary. It shows the 9 most-liked posts from a topic of 121, in their original order, with the accepted answer included where one exists. It is a reading aid and it will miss nuance — the full topic is the record.
BW
b.wikstromTL2 Solution22 Mar 2026#8
f.lindholm, post #2: The baseline characteristics table is the single most useful page for the questions that get asked here, because it tells you who the result applies to. None of the above is medical advice and I am not qualified to give any. Go to post

The figures usually contain the finding and the text usually contains the interpretation. Separating them for the first twenty minutes is a discipline worth keeping.

For what it is worth, the same held on the two occasions I checked.

25 likes in reply to #2 4mo
K
KnowltonTL3Regular29 Mar 2026#22

Post #21 is the version of this I will quote in future. One addition.

The baseline characteristics table is the single most useful page for the questions that get asked here, because it tells you who the result applies to.

29 likes 4mo
V
VThorvaldsenTL3Regular31 Mar 2026#28

The most common failure mode is spending fifty minutes on the effect size and ten on the population. Reversing that ratio would improve most sessions.

Caveat: everything above assumes the paperwork is what it says it is.

28 likes 4mo
EC
excursion_checkTL3Regular1 Apr 2026#31

Taking post #28 at face value and following it one step further.

The figures usually contain the finding and the text usually contains the interpretation. Separating them for the first twenty minutes is a discipline worth keeping.

32 likes 4mo
AW
a.weissTL215 Apr 2026#70
t.abubakar, post #36: Post #35 put the caveat in the right place and I want to underline it. Where the group cannot agree, record the disagreement rather than resolving it by seniority. The recorded disagreement is more honest and more useful later. Go to post

Adding the measurement that post #69 says would settle it.

The figures usually contain the finding and the text usually contains the interpretation. Separating them for the first twenty minutes is a discipline worth keeping.

This is the version I would want a new member to read first.

28 likes in reply to #36 3mo
G
GDashwoodTL3Regular18 Apr 2026#79
t.abubakar, post #36: Post #35 put the caveat in the right place and I want to underline it. Where the group cannot agree, record the disagreement rather than resolving it by seniority. The recorded disagreement is more honest and more useful later. Go to post

Narrowing post #76, because the general version has more than one answer.

Reading order that works for these sessions: registry entry, methods, baseline table, primary result, then abstract last. Reading the abstract first anchors everything that follows.

30 likes in reply to #36 3mo
NV
n.vogelTL222 Apr 2026#91

The baseline characteristics table is the single most useful page for the questions that get asked here, because it tells you who the result applies to.

31 likes 3mo
SF
s.ferreiraTL223 Apr 2026#97
excursion_check, post #31: Taking post #28 at face value and following it one step further. The figures usually contain the finding and the text usually contains the interpretation. Separating them for the first twenty minutes is a discipline worth keeping. Go to post

Picking up post #94: that is the part I would want checked first.

The figures usually contain the finding and the text usually contains the interpretation. Separating them for the first twenty minutes is a discipline worth keeping.

If that is already documented somewhere, ignore me and link it.

29 likes in reply to #31 3mo
CN
c.nybergTL227 Apr 2026#109

Reading order that works for these sessions: registry entry, methods, baseline table, primary result, then abstract last. Reading the abstract first anchors everything that follows.

29 likes 3mo

Read the full topic (121 posts)

Suggested topics

TopicParticipantsRepliesViewsActivity
Journal club: SUSTAIN 6 and its retinopathy signal
On the subject in the title: Journal club: SUSTAIN 6 and its retinopathy signal Working notes rather than a conclusion. Reading SUSTAIN 6 ( N Engl J Med , 2016) for the population rather than the effect,…
LAMRZHOJI+110 122 46k 1d
Journal club: how we handle discontinuation in obesity trials — what changed since
Journal club: how we handle discontinuation in obesity trials — what changed since — setting out what I have, and where I think it stops being reliable. Session topic: STEP 4 ( JAMA , 2021). Please read it…
OVFVIISLJB+14 18 35k 8mo
Follow-up: Journal club: the retatrutide phase 2 obesity paper
On the subject in the title: Journal club: the retatrutide phase 2 obesity paper Working notes rather than a conclusion. A follow-up question about retatrutide phase 2 obesity paper that I did not know to ask…
NDNRRRSIS+20 24 8.7k 16mo
Revisiting: Journal club: SURMOUNT-OSA and a hard endpoint in a soft field
Revisiting: Journal club: SURMOUNT-OSA and a hard endpoint in a soft field — setting out what I have, and where I think it stops being reliable. Collecting what is known about SURMOUNT-OSA in one place,…
FPHMLPAAVB+108 122 52k 7d
Journal club: SELECT, absolute risk, and how it was reported
Journal club: SELECT, absolute risk, and how it was reported Writing it up because I had to work it out twice and would rather nobody else did. A question about what the numbers mean rather than what they…
MSFVJF 2 52k 1mo

Related topics — sharing the tags number needed to treat, randomised trial, journal club

TopicParticipantsRepliesViewsActivity
Is "synergy" the right word for the combination data?
Is "synergy" the right word for the combination data? — that is the question, and I have not found it answered plainly anywhere I have looked. Setting out what I think I know about this compound and asking…
JSRASMNAKF+5 9 13k 25d
[2026 update] What the GIP component of tirzepatide is thought to contribute, and how confident we can be
The question in the title: What the GIP component of tirzepatide is thought to contribute, and how confident we can be I will give what I have already checked below so nobody repeats it. I would like to know…
DSSBBDALCD+109 124 31k 10mo
About the Journal club category
Our recurring session. One named paper per topic, methods first, conclusions last. Everyone reads before posting. This post is a community wiki: any member at trust level 3 or above can edit it, and every…
KHSDEMSCA+2 6 12k 16mo
Why retatrutide discussion here is more cautious than elsewhere — one year on
Asking directly, because I could not find a straight answer: Why retatrutide discussion here is more cautious than elsewhere — one year on Two things I would like separated before anyone answers on…
DBHCNRKKI+92 97 3.6k 20h
Why fasting instructions for oral semaglutide are not optional advice — does this still hold?
Asking directly, because I could not find a straight answer: Why fasting instructions for oral semaglutide are not optional advice — does this still hold? A methods question rather than a substantive one,…
MVEBATJSI+98 106 3.1k 10mo